Sunday, 22 November 2026

The Humourless Scottish Git

"Another victim of our childish taunting was the Scottish comic publisher D. C. Thomson. Viz owed a great deal to the Beano, the Dandy and other traditional British comics as our stock in trade was to lampoon their contents or hijack their formats for our own purposes. D. C. Thomson, publishers of both the Dandy and the Beano, had a reputation for being an outdated, Victorian institution."
-- Rude Kids: The Unfeasible Story of Viz, Chris Donald

Whilst Viz's early parodies of D. C. Thomson strips such as Black Bag: The Viz Wonder Bin Liner, Biffa Bacon and The Three Chairs appear to have been viewed by the publisher as harmless, in August 1988, issue #31, they published something rather less subtle.

Scan from r/Viz

Desperately Unfunny Dan got the comic slapped down with a formal warning from D. C.'s lawyers, and they did for a time steer clear of Beano and Dandy spoofs after that. But before long they started cropping up again, and in mid-1990 John Brown Publishing Ltd found itself with a second warning after they published The McBroons. Other strips such as Roger the Lodger and Little Plumber seemed to have passed by without comment, but in late 1994 Viz's take on Keyhole Kate, the hopefully self-explanatory Arsehole Kate, resulted in D. C. Thomson putting editor Chris Donald and co. on a final warning.

A final warning which it took them all of five months to break with Wanker Watson in issue #71, which resulted in John Brown promising to withdraw that issue from sale, and not to publish any future parodies of D. C. Thomson characters.

Donald quickly found a loophole -- as he puts it in Rude Kids, "there was nothing to stop us taking the piss out of D. C. Thomson personally". And so it came to pass that just two issues later, D. C. Thompson -- The Humourless Scottish Git went to press:

Scan from Bluesky

But Donald was a bit surprised by D. C. Thomson's response... which came not from their lawyers, but from someone Viz had had a rather more cordial relationship with, Dandy editor Morris Heggie.

In the issue of the Dandy dated 26 August 1995, this edition of The Jocks and the Geordies ran:


TJatG had not run in the Dandy since the start of the nineties; artist Jimmy Hughes, who had drawn the strip since its inception in the mid-seventies, had retired and it was decided to end the strip rather than seek a replacement. But obviously this strip needs to be The Jocks and the Geordies for it to work. (Elsewhere in Rude Kids, Donald relates a letter sent in by T. A. Acton, a Doctor of Philosophy and Reader in Romany Studies at Thames Polytechnic following the publication of a certain strip starring some thieving bastards, which concluded by calling them "a bunch of lazy-minded, chicken-shit Geordie wankers".) The "back by popular request" claim must be a white lie for the sake of most of the Dandy's readership, since there are no JaG strips in subsequent issues. (The one-off looks to be the work of Steve Bright to me. Bright regularly ghosted strips when the usual artist was unavailable, and his take on Hughes is almost indistinguishable from the original; in fact I suspect he may have previously ghosted the strip towards the end of its run. The giveaway is the style 'Don Christopher' -- a direct caricature of Chris Donald -- is drawn in.)

At this point there were so many different stories in the Dandy that some did not run every week -- it had recently picked up a few survivors from the defunct Beezer and Topper, and Tom Paterson appears to have been drawing so many different stories for the comic at this point that some of them had to run in rotation. Although presumably an accident rather than design, it is quite possible that this stopped readers from being confused by an old story coming back for a single issue.

More pertinently, this strip successfully de-escalated the situation, and the relationship between the Jocks and John Brown was far more relaxed from that point on.


And just one issue later, they put Corky the Twat in pride of place on the front cover.

With thanks to danofthewibble.bsky.social, the Viz thread on Cook'd and Bomb'd, the people whose scans I 'borrowed' for this piece, and Paul Hayes for a very interesting newspaper article I unfortunately couldn't find a place for in the post itself

1 comment:

  1. I've always loved the Viz parodies of classic comics - actually, I think some of the all-time best were Fleetway characters rather than DC Thomson - Ivor Better and Tony Worse was hilariously silly, and Arseache (Faceache) perhaps the greatest of them all! I do love that Jocks and Geordies strip, though - the perfect way to turn a nasty legal dispute into a friendly rivalry!

    ReplyDelete